GWT Designer for Eclipse 3.6 can cause project compile freeze

I've stumbled upon a bug with my configuration for JBoss Envers today, despite having integration tests all over the application. I have to admit, it casted a dark shadow of doubt about the value of all the tests for a moment. I've been practicing TDD since 2005, and frankly speaking, I should have been smarter than that.

My fault was simple. I've started using Envers the right way, with exploratory tests and a prototype. Then I've deleted the prototype and created some integration tests using in-memory H2 that looked more or less like this example:

@Test
public void savingAndUpdatingPersonShouldCreateTwoHistoricalVersions() {
    //given
    Person person = createAndSavePerson();
    String oldFirstName = person.getFirstName();
    String newFirstName = oldFirstName + "NEW";

    //when
    updatePersonWithNewName(person, newFirstName);

    //then
    verifyTwoHistoricalVersionsWereSaved(oldFirstName, newFirstName);
}

private Person createAndSavePerson() {
    Transaction transaction = session.beginTransaction();
    Person person = PersonFactory.createPerson();
    session.save(person);
    transaction.commit();
    return person;
}    

private void updatePersonWithNewName(Person person, String newName) {
    Transaction transaction = session.beginTransaction();
    person.setFirstName(newName);
    session.update(person);
    transaction.commit();
}

private void verifyTwoHistoricalVersionsWereSaved(String oldFirstName, String newFirstName) {
    List<Object[]> personRevisions = getPersonRevisions();
    assertEquals(2, personRevisions.size());
    assertEquals(oldFirstName, ((Person)personRevisions.get(0)[0]).getFirstName());
    assertEquals(newFirstName, ((Person)personRevisions.get(1)[0]).getFirstName());
}

private List<Object[]> getPersonRevisions() {
    Transaction transaction = session.beginTransaction();
    AuditReader auditReader = AuditReaderFactory.get(session);
    List<Object[]> personRevisions = auditReader.createQuery()
            .forRevisionsOfEntity(Person.class, false, true)
            .getResultList();
    transaction.commit();
    return personRevisions;
}

Because Envers inserts audit data when the transaction is commited (in a new temporary session), I thought I have to create and commit the transaction manually. And that is true to some point.

My fault was that I didn't have an end-to-end integration/acceptance test, that would call to entry point of the application (in this case a service which is called by GWT via RPC), because then I'd notice, that the Spring @Transactional annotation, and calling transaction.commit() are two, very different things.

Spring @Transactional annotation will use a transaction manager configured for the application. Envers on the other hand is used by subscribing a listener to hibernate's SessionFactory like this:

<bean id="sessionFactory" class="org.springframework.orm.hibernate3.annotation.AnnotationSessionFactoryBean" >        
...
 <property name="eventListeners">
     <map key-type="java.lang.String" value-type="org.hibernate.event.EventListeners">
         <entry key="post-insert" value-ref="auditEventListener"/>
         <entry key="post-update" value-ref="auditEventListener"/>
         <entry key="post-delete" value-ref="auditEventListener"/>
         <entry key="pre-collection-update" value-ref="auditEventListener"/>
         <entry key="pre-collection-remove" value-ref="auditEventListener"/>
         <entry key="post-collection-recreate" value-ref="auditEventListener"/>
     </map>
 </property>
</bean>

<bean id="auditEventListener" class="org.hibernate.envers.event.AuditEventListener" />

Envers creates and collects something called AuditWorkUnits whenever you update/delete/insert audited entities, but audit tables are not populated until something calls AuditProcess.beforeCompletion, which makes sense. If you are using org.hibernate.transaction.JDBCTransaction manually, this is called on commit() when notifying all subscribed javax.transaction.Synchronization objects (and enver's AuditProcess is one of them).

The problem was, that I used a wrong transaction manager.

<bean id="transactionManager" class="org.springframework.jdbc.datasource.DataSourceTransactionManager" >
    <property name="dataSource" ref="dataSource"/>
</bean>

This transaction manager doesn't know anything about hibernate and doesn't use org.hibernate.transaction.JDBCTransaction. While Synchronization is an interface from javax.transaction package, DataSourceTransactionManager doesn't use it (maybe because of simplicity, I didn't dig deep enough in org.springframework.jdbc.datasource), and thus Envers works fine except not pushing the data to the database.

Which is the whole point of using Envers.

Use right tools for the task, they say. The whole problem is solved by using a transaction manager that is well aware of hibernate underneath.

<bean id="transactionManager" class="org.springframework.orm.hibernate3.HibernateTransactionManager" >
    <property name="sessionFactory" ref="sessionFactory"/>
</bean>

Lesson learned: always make sure your acceptance tests are testing the right thing. If there is a doubt about the value of your tests, you just don't have enough of them,

This article is a short how-to about multi-module project setup with usage of the Gradle automation build tool.

Here's how Rich Seller, a StackOverflow user, describes Gradle:

Gradle promises to hit the sweet spot between Ant and Maven. It uses Ivy's approach for dependency resolution. It allows for convention over configuration but also includes Ant tasks as first class citizens. It also wisely allows you to use existing Maven/Ivy repositories.

So why would one use yet another JVM build tool such as Gradle? The answer is simple: to avoid frustration involved by Ant or Maven.

Short story

I was fooling around with some fresh proof of concept and needed a build tool. I'm pretty familiar with Maven so created project from an artifact, and opened the build file, pom.xml for further tuning.
I had been using Grails with its own build system (similar to Gradle, btw) already for some time up then, so after quite a time without Maven, I looked on the pom.xml and found it to be really repulsive.

Once again I felt clearly: XML is not for humans.

After quick googling I found Gradle. It was still in beta (0.8 version) back then, but it's configured with Groovy DSL and that's what a human likes :)

Where are we

In the time Ant can be met but among IT guerrillas, Maven is still on top and couple of others like for example Ivy conquer for the best position, Gradle smoothly went into its mature age. It's now available in 1.3 version, released at 20th of November 2012. I'm glad to recommend it to anyone looking for relief from XML configured tools, or for anyone just looking for simple, elastic and powerful build tool.

Lets build

I have already written about basic project structure so I skip this one, reminding only the basic project structure:

<project root>

│

├── build.gradle

└── src

    ├── main

    │   ├── java

    │   └── groovy

    │

    └── test

        ├── java

        └── groovy

Have I just referred myself for the 1st time? Achievement unlocked! ;)

Gradle as most build tools is run from a command line with parameters. The main parameter for Gradle is a 'task name', for example we can run a command: gradle build.
There is no 'create project' task, so the directory structure has to be created by hand. This isn't a hassle though.
Java and groovy sub-folders aren't always mandatory. They depend on what compile plugin is used.

Parent project

Consider an example project 'the-app' of three modules, let say:

1. database communication layer
2. domain model and services layer
3. web presentation layer

Our project directory tree will look like:

the-app

│

├── dao-layer

│   └── src

│

├── domain-model

│   └── src

│

├── web-frontend

│   └── src

│

├── build.gradle

└── settings.gradle

the-app itself has no src sub-folder as its purpose is only to contain sub-projects and build configuration. If needed it could've been provided with own src though.

To glue modules we need to fill settings.gradle file under the-app directory with a single line of content specifying module names:

include 'dao-layer', 'domain-model', 'web-frontend'

Now the gradle projects command can be executed to obtain such a result:

:projects


------------------------------------------------------------

Root project

------------------------------------------------------------


Root project 'the-app'

+--- Project ':dao-layer'

+--- Project ':domain-model'

\--- Project ':web-frontend'

...so we know that Gradle noticed the modules. However gradle build command won't run successful yet because build.gradle file is still empty.

Sub project

As in Maven we can create separate build config file per each module. Let say we starting from DAO layer.
Thus we create a new file the-app/dao-layer/build.gradle with a line of basic build info (notice the new build.gradle was created under sub-project directory):

apply plugin: 'java'

This single line of config for any of modules is enough to execute gradle build command under the-app directory with following result:

:dao-layer:compileJava

:dao-layer:processResources UP-TO-DATE

:dao-layer:classes

:dao-layer:jar

:dao-layer:assemble

:dao-layer:compileTestJava UP-TO-DATE

:dao-layer:processTestResources UP-TO-DATE

:dao-layer:testClasses UP-TO-DATE

:dao-layer:test

:dao-layer:check

:dao-layer:build


BUILD SUCCESSFUL


Total time: 3.256 secs

To use Groovy plugin slightly more configuration is needed:

apply plugin: 'groovy'


repositories {

    mavenLocal()

    mavenCentral()

}


dependencies {

    groovy 'org.codehaus.groovy:groovy-all:2.0.5'

}

At lines 3 to 6 Maven repositories are set. At line 9 dependency with groovy library version is specified. Of course plugin as 'java', 'groovy' and many more can be mixed each other.

If we have settings.gradle file and a build.gradle file for each module, there is no need for parent the-app/build.gradle file at all. Sure that's true but we can go another, better way.

One file to rule them all

Instead of creating many build.gradle config files, one per each module, we can use only the parent's one and make it a bit more juicy. So let us move the the-app/dao-layer/build.gradle a level up to the-app/build-gradle and fill it with new statements to achieve full project configuration:

def langLevel = 1.7


allprojects {


    apply plugin: 'idea'


    group = 'com.tamashumi'

    version = '0.1'

}


subprojects {


    apply plugin: 'groovy'


    sourceCompatibility = langLevel

    targetCompatibility = langLevel


    repositories {

        mavenLocal()

        mavenCentral()

    }


    dependencies {

        groovy 'org.codehaus.groovy:groovy-all:2.0.5'

        testCompile 'org.spockframework:spock-core:0.7-groovy-2.0'

    }

}


project(':dao-layer') {


    dependencies {

        compile 'org.hibernate:hibernate-core:4.1.7.Final'

    }

}


project(':domain-model') {


    dependencies {

        compile project(':dao-layer')

    }

}


project(':web-frontend') {


    apply plugin: 'war'


    dependencies {

        compile project(':domain-model')

        compile 'org.springframework:spring-webmvc:3.1.2.RELEASE'

    }

}


idea {

    project {

        jdkName = langLevel

        languageLevel = langLevel

    }

}

At the beginning simple variable langLevel is declared. It's worth knowing that we can use almost any Groovy code inside build.gradle file, statements like for example if conditions, for/while loops, closures, switch-case, etc... Quite an advantage over inflexible XML, isn't it?

Next the allProjects block. Any configuration placed in it will influence - what a surprise - all projects, so the parent itself and sub-projects (modules). Inside of the block we have the IDE (Intellij Idea) plugin applied which I wrote more about in previous article (look under "IDE Integration" heading). Enough to say that with this plugin applied here, command gradle idea will generate Idea's project files with modules structure and dependencies. This works really well and plugins for other IDEs are available too.
Remaining two lines at this block define group and version for the project, similar as this is done by Maven.

After that subProjects block appears. It's related to all modules but not the parent project. So here the Groovy language plugin is applied, as all modules are assumed to be written in Groovy.
Below source and target language level are set.
After that come references to standard Maven repositories.
At the end of the block dependencies to groovy version and test library - Spock framework.

Following blocks, project(':module-name'), are responsible for each module configuration. They may be omitted unless allProjects or subProjects configure what's necessary for a specific module. In the example per module configuration goes as follow:

• Dao-layer module has dependency to an ORM library - Hibernate
• Domain-model module relies on dao-layer as a dependency. Keyword project is used here again for a reference to other module.
• Web-frontend applies 'war' plugin which build this module into java web archive. Besides it referes to domain-model module and also use Spring MVC framework dependency.

At the end in idea block is basic info for IDE plugin. Those are parameters corresponding to the Idea's project general settings visible on the following screen shot.


jdkName should match the IDE's SDK name otherwise it has to be set manually under IDE on each Idea's project files (re)generation with gradle idea command.

Is that it?

In the matter of simplicity - yes. That's enough to automate modular application build with custom configuration per module. Not a rocket science, huh? Think about Maven's XML. It would take more effort to setup the same and still achieve less expressible configuration quite far from user-friendly.

Check the online user guide for a lot of configuration possibilities or better download Gradle and see the sample projects.
As a tasty bait take a look for this short choice of available plugins:

• java
• groovy
• scala
• cpp
• eclipse
• netbeans
• ida
• maven
• osgi
• war
• ear
• sonar
• project-report
• signing

and more, 3rd party plugins...